Monday, March 18, 2024

DONE (continued)

Hey - guess what!  You hardcore, lifetime followers of the blournal will remember the Great Water Heater Replacement of 2006.  That was the one where I used every tool I own to install a tankless heater in my basement.  Well, that thing finally quit.

For "reasons", I thought it best to clean the little screen that filters the water coming into it.  It's actually pretty good preventive maintenance after 17 years of buildup.  I switched off the power, unscrewed the little filter, screwed the new one in, and turned the power back on.  Takes like 30 seconds.  Plus 17 years.

The water heater never worked again.  The flame wouldn't come back on.  Mind you - I never even opened this thing up.  The filter is on the outside.  Pretty sure it was just a coincidence.

I called the company and they confirmed that.  The motherboard had fried and, sorry to say, they don't make that part anymore.  I had to order a new unit.  Good news I suppose is that the new one is pretty much a drop-in replacement so it would require far fewer tools and time.  Likely less than an hour, which is nice because by the time it shows up I'll be on my 3rd day without hot water.

I finally got the new water heater and installed it - just as easily as I had hoped!  I switched in on, very very excited to take a hot shower, and it wouldn't make flame.  Seems this brand new unit was defective.  I got on the phone to the manufacturer and they confirmed that.  Then they promised to mail out a replacement part that I could install myself, which is just terrific.  Really, really good stuff.  Who doesn't want the opportunity to fix something brand new?

They never did get the part mailed out that day, which was a Friday, so I just had to wait two more days until Monday for them to send it, so that means I'll only be without hot water for about six days, which honestly is less than a full week.

After installing the new part, the unit still didn't really want to stay lit, so all I really had to do was hire a plumber to remove about 35' of 3/4" gas piping in my house and replace it with 1".  You might remember a post from 2006 entitled "Your Total is $111.08"

Here's a photo called

"Your Total is $458.06"

In fairness, I did buy more than I thought I would need so I wouldn't have to run back to the store in the middle of the job, but I still contend that (inflation adjusted) this doesn't look more than $38 worth of junk.  I got about $115 back.

If you like, you can compare the old install to the new.  Very similar, but you may note the new 1" gas pipe and possibly even the two drains added for posterity.  Before you complain too heavily about how my basement looks, understand that my home was built the same year as the Arab-Israeli War.  There.  That reference should bring clarity.


In all, the new unit doesn't quite work as well as the last one.  The problem is I upgraded and this unit works best when it has more water flowing through it.  With lower flows it sounds a little like a small airplane.  If I open up another faucet somewhere, it smoothes right out and is quite quiet.  I am pleased to have just used those two words right next to each other.  

But I can't complain.  After receiving a DOA, fixing a brand new unit by myself, and paying a plumber to run new gas piping in my basement, plus going six days without hot water in my home, the new heater works really well if I just use a ton more water and gas.  A real upgrade!

Hey - I hope you changed those smoke detector batteries last week!